Meet my Crabby Roommate
When Self-Doubt Masquerades as Protection
"You wouldn't worry so much about what others think of you if you realized how seldom they do." — Eleanor Roosevelt
I call her my "Crabby Roommate," because she's a cynical 20-something college co-ed who doubts my intelligence and is absolutely certain I'm not prepared for whatever I'm undertaking.
She's not real, of course. Her irrational voice lives only in my head. But if I'm not careful, her negative self-talk drowns out my wisdom and inner-resourcefulness like a fire hose pointed directly at my confidence.
When Your Inner Critic Takes the Mic
You know your Crabby Roommate has seized control when:
⚠️ You're about to hit "publish" and suddenly convince yourself it's terrible
⚠️ An opportunity arrives and your first thought is "Who am I to do this?"
⚠️ You rehearse conversations in your head, preparing for imaginary criticism
A client recently confessed, "I had a keynote speech prepared for weeks. The morning of, my Crabby Roommate convinced me the entire presentation was garbage. I rewrote it from scratch at 6 AM and bombed because I was exhausted and scattered."
That voice? It screams loudest when we have new opportunities and step out of our comfort zone.
Listening to Old Stories
Before I understood what was happening, my Crabby Roommate ran the show.
She'd pipe up during podcast interviews: "They're going to find out you don't know what you're talking about." She'd whisper during client calls: "You're not smart enough to help this person." She'd shout when I was writing my book: "Who's going to want to read this?"
The breaking point came when I was preparing for a speaking engagement at a leadership conference. I'd been invited because of my expertise, yet my Crabby Roommate had me convinced I was a fraud. I remember standing backstage, heart pounding, thinking "I can't do this." Then I had a radical thought: "What if this voice isn't telling me the truth?" That question changed everything.
The Truth About Your Inner Critic
Here's what I've learned: The voice of the inner critic is an expression of the safety instinct that resides within all of us.
Even people who appear supremely confident and self-assured battle with this voice of doubt, because we're all hardwired the same way—to keep ourselves safe from potential risk, conflict, failure, and embarrassment.
Your Crabby Roommate isn't working with current information. Their worry usually stems from old childhood fears, perhaps when an authority figure doubted your abilities, or from a past experience when you were still learning and made mistakes (as all learners do).
Mine was formed when I was seven years old and my second-grade teacher told my mother I wasn't "college material." That became the voice that questioned every professional accomplishment for the next three decades.
Because the goal of the inner critic is to keep you safe, it bullies, judges, and criticizes you. It thinks if it can make you small enough, you'll never risk being hurt, rejected, or proven inadequate.
But here's the plot twist: Playing small hurts MORE than risking failure ever could.
When Growth Feels Dangerous
A client shared this recently: "I got promoted to VP, and instead of celebrating, I spent three days spiraling about all the ways I was going to fail. My Crabby Roommate had me convinced they'd made a mistake choosing me."
Sound familiar?
Your inner critic speaks loudest when you're growing, stretching, and moving into new territory that takes you outside your comfort zone. It interprets growth as danger. Every time you level up, it panics and tries to pull you back to familiar ground—even if that ground no longer serves you.
The discomfort you feel isn't evidence you're on the wrong path. It's often evidence you're on exactly the RIGHT path, and your old programming is terrified of what that means.
Your Inner Critic Survival Guide
Name the Voice: The first step to combating the influence of the inner critic is understanding how it shows up in your thinking with old perspectives that probably no longer fit.
When that voice starts up, try this: "Oh, hello Crabby Roommate. I see you're worried. Thanks for the input, but I've got this."
Simply acknowledging it—naming it as separate from YOU—diminishes its power dramatically.
Question the Source: Ask yourself: "Whose voice is this really? Where did I first learn to doubt myself this way?"
Often you'll discover it's not your voice at all. It's a parent's anxiety, a teacher's dismissiveness, a past partner's criticism—old recordings playing on repeat.
Gather Current Evidence: My Crabby Roommate loves to ignore any evidence of my competence. So I keep a "proof file"—emails from grateful clients, testimonials, moments I'm proud of. When she starts spinning stories, I counter with facts.
You've done hard things before. You've figured things out. You've grown and learned and succeeded. Don't let your inner critic erase that track record.
What Becomes Possible
These days, when my Crabby Roommate shows up (and she still does), I recognize her immediately. "Ah, there you are. You must think I'm about to do something important." And then I do it anyway.
The magic isn't in silencing the voice completely—it's in refusing to let that voice make your decisions.
Learning to notice the voice of the inner critic is one of the first powerful tools I teach clients who want to resourcefully take back their power. Together we make a game plan for recognizing when and how the inner critic shows up, and we develop strategies and mindsets to help send it away.
Just imagine what will be possible in your life when you learn to notice and NAME the inner critic energy that lives within you and develop the courage to move forward despite its protests.
Your Crabby Roommate will always be there. But she doesn't get to be the landlord anymore.
Who's YOUR inner critic?
What does their voice sound like? And more importantly—what would you dare to do if you stopped believing everything they said?
Celebrating your courage to outgrow old stories,
💫 Andrea
The Global Authority on Cognitive Reframing
Ready to transform your perspective and your leadership from the inside out?
✧ Private Coaching Create lasting change through personalized guidance. [Schedule a Discovery Call]
✧ NCR Workshops Experience NAME, CLAIM AND REFRAME® in an intimate group setting. [Join Waitlist]
✧The Book, Discover your path to authentic power with "Name, Claim & Reframe." [Get Your Copy]
✧ The Workbook Put insights into action with practical tools and exercises. [Order Now]"
BONUS: Not sure where to start?
Take the What’s Your Leadership Style Quiz!
I'm Andrea Mein DeWitt—a leadership coach, author, and self-proclaimed warrior in recovery who helps bold souls reclaim their power and unleash their full potential. After transforming my 32-year career in education into a dynamic coaching practice, I now guide people through my signature NAME, CLAIM AND REFRAME® methodology.
My book Name, Claim & Reframe: Your Path to a Well-Lived Life was featured on the TODAY Show as 2023's best motivational read. Writing from the foggy San Francisco Bay Area, I believe that life's challenges are invitations to discover who you're meant to be.
